Five reasons Arsenal should not sign Morgan Rogers this summer

Share
Five reasons Arsenal should not sign Morgan Rogers this summer

At a Glance:

  • Arsenal are looking to go big again in the transfer window this summer.
  • The Gunners are reportedly interested in Morgan Rogers.
  • Here are five reasons why they shouldn’t sign the Aston Villa midfielder.

Arsenal are seemingly set to invest heavily in the transfer window once again this summer, and Aston Villa midfielder Morgan Rogers appears to be one of Andrea Berta’s primary targets.

The Gunners spent around £250 million on eight new players last summer, and despite winning the Premier League title this season, are now planning more ambitious moves. Reports suggest Berta and Mikel Arteta sense they have a window to dominate English football due to the instability at rival clubs, and the pair are subsequently looking to pounce on this opportunity.

While another £250 million outlay is unlikely, Fabrizio Romano revealed on Monday that at least three signings are expected at the Emirates. A left-winger, a central midfielder and a right-back are said to be the priority areas, while a striker could also follow.

Rogers is on Arsenal’s radar, with Villa reportedly placing an £80 million price tag on the number ten. However, here are five reasons why the Gunners shouldn’t sign the England international.

The price for Morgan Rogers is too high

Based on his output over the last two seasons, there is no doubt that Rogers is a good player who can contribute at a high level. He now has a Europa League winners’ medal in his back pocket and will be competing at the World Cup with England in the summer.

However, there are question marks around the prospective price tag. While £80 million may not seem too steep in the current market, it’s very unlikely Villa will actually sanction Rogers’ departure at this value.

Reports have already emerged indicating that Villa don’t want to sell Rogers. This isn’t exactly a surprise given his importance to Unai Emery’s team, and it suggests they won’t settle for anything that isn’t astronomical.

While a good player, is Rogers worth forking out Declan Rice money for? Probably not, as he’s not likely to be transformative in the way the former West Ham man has been for Arsenal.

Morgan Rogers is not a winger

Arsenal’s priority this summer is understood to be a top-class left-winger. Given Leandro Trossard and Gabriel Martinelli’s respective struggles this term, this isn’t a huge surprise.

Rogers simply isn’t a winger, and never has been. He’s spent almost all of his career to date as a number ten or second striker to Ollie Watkins.

While he could transition into being a wide player, it’s not clear whether his ball-carrying would translate to these areas of the pitch. If you’re spending potentially upwards of £100 million on a player, you want to be sure that they can play in the role you want them to play to a high level, and they just cannot be sure that Rogers will be an elite winger. It’d be one hell of a gamble.

Morgan Rogers lacks attributes Arsenal need

Rogers’ strongest attributes are his ball-carrying in central areas and his shooting from range. He thrives in a team that isn’t possession-dominant and purposely creates moments of transition to exploit the opposition.

Arsenal do not play in this way. In the Gunners’ ideal game, they have all of the ball in and around the opponents’ final third.

Rogers does not have the attributes to help Arsenal break teams down through intricate passing patterns. While he may be capable of scoring a few long shots in a season, this unsustainable route to goal isn’t what is going to elevate the level of the Gunners’ attack.

Arteta’s team have looked at their best when Martin Odegaard has been playing at his highest level, because of what the best version of Odegaard brings – ball progression through mid-blocks and creative passing in the final third. Rogers provides neither of these attributes.

Morgan Rogers’ underlying numbers are concerning

Stats aren’t for everyone, but they do paint a good picture of a player. When looking through Rogers’ statistical profile, it becomes clear that his output may not be sustainable.

He scored 14 goals from 6.78 expected goals and registered eleven assists from 4.3 expected assists. While it can be assumed based on the evidence that he is a significantly above-average finisher, this level of overperformance is rarely sustainable, and this began to show itself in the second half of the season when his numbers dried up.

Morgan Rogers’ 2025/26 Statistics per 90 (All Competitions)
StatValuePercentile Rank
Goals0.2776th
Non-Penalty Expected Goals0.1959th
Shots2.373rd
Expected Assists0.1238th
Successful Passes21.837th
Successful Dribbles1.1555th

Additionally, his underlying numbers from a creative standpoint are poor, and he puts up next to nothing defensively – which won’t run in an Arteta team.

Arsenal already have too many number tens

Possibly the most pertinent reason for not signing Rogers is that Arsenal already have an excess of players in his position. This is said to be a concern for those within the North London club, who don’t view the addition as particularly necessary.

Martin Odegaard, Eberechi Eze, Max Dowman and Ethan Nwaneri are already in Arteta’s squad, and the four likely can’t coexist. It’s very possible that Nwaneri is pushed out of the door this summer because of this.

There is no reason to sign Rogers when you already have three players in this position, while Eze is arguably a similar player. If Rogers were to arrive, Eze may be left somewhat redundant.

Alfie Cairns Culshaw is a writer for ReadArsenal and is an experienced sports journalist who has over four years of experience covering football. He's written extensively for GiveMeSport, SportBible and Arsenal Insider in the past, specialising in Arsenal and the Premier League. Alfie holds a first class degree in Journalism from the University of Sussex and has personally run his own website in the past. When not writing about football, Alfie is playing the sport himself or attending matches at the Emirates. Follow Alfie on LinkedIn, https://www.linkedin.com/in/alfie-cairns-culshaw-12bb74188/ and on X, https://x.com/AlfieCulshaw.

View all articles →
dave.sport

dave.sport is in beta

We are building a new home for independent sports coverage. dave.sport is currently in beta, with new features and publisher tools rolling out as we test what fans need most.

Explore the beta
Discover more from Read Arsenal

Add Read Arsenal as a preferred source on Google to see more of our reporting.

Follow
Keep Reading

Declan Rice Shows Arsenal’s Set-Piece School Is Now An England Weapon

related.